woman 1006100 1920

Concussion position and consensus statements fall short

 

Underrepresentation of female athletes in research informing influential consensus and position statements on concussion: a review and synthesis of evidence

D’Lauro C, Jones ER, Swope LM, Anderson MN, Broglio S, Schmidt JD. Br J Sports Med. July 18, 2022: bjsports-2021-105045. doi: 10.1136/bjsports-2021-105045.

Full text freely available

Take home message

Female athletes are underrepresented in the data used to inform concussion consensus and position papers.

Background

Medical professionals rely on concussion consensus and position statements to design their diagnosis and treatment protocols. These papers are based on evidence suggesting that men and women have similar presentations and recoveries; However, there may be clinically meaningful differences in concussion risk, presentation, and recovery among male, female, transgender, and non-binary athletes. Although this disparity is recognized, it remains unclear whether a gender imbalance in concussion research influences concussion consensus and position statements.

Study aim

The authors evaluated the three influential consensus and position papers to quantify the composition of the research data for clinical practice among female athletes.

Methods

The authors conducted a PubMed search in August 2021 using the terms “concussion position statement” and “concussion consensus statement.” The English language was the only limitation. The authors selected the International Conference on Concussion in Sport (ICCS, 2017), the National Athletic Training Association (NATA) Concussion Position Statement (2014), and the American Medical Society for Sports Medicine (AMSSM) Concussion Position Statement (2019). They selected these statements based on citation patterns, the publication of updated versions, and research into the use of these documents by physicians. The authors counted the total number of male and female participants in each study cited in the three documents that recorded or implied gender information. If the original authors failed to clearly state the ratio for sex or gender, the current authors excluded that study.

Results

Across all three statements, 375 citations were reviewed, including 171 articles with relevant gender and sex information (93 from NATA, 17 from ICCS and 68 from AMSSM). Eighteen were cited in two of the statements, while all three cited zero. Overall, the studies were ~80% male (NATA 80%, ICCS 88%, and AMSSM 79% male). Only two manuscripts contained an all-female sample, while 69 manuscripts contained an all-male sample.

Viewpoints

The information doctors receive about concussion care relies heavily on data among men. This is alarming because medical professionals rely on these expert-curated documents to guide their clinical decisions; however, the scientific evidence fails to adequately represent female and non-binary athletes. This disparity can lead to unequal treatment of these athletes who sustain a concussion. For example, men and women differ in responses to medications, substance abuse, and risk factors for other health problems. Therefore, this could indicate that female and non-binary athletes respond differently than men to concussion, both on a physiological and psychosocial level. It would be interesting to see if this trend also occurs in other consensus and position statements. Additionally, it would be helpful if future statements clearly describe how well the evidence represents the intended patient population (e.g., sex, gender, race/ethnicity).

Clinical implications

Consensus and position statements should be a starting point and not a shortcut. Medical professionals should seek research beyond consensus and position statements to guide their concussion practices toward female and non-binary athletes. Additionally, when educating a female or non-binary athlete about what to expect after a concussion, we should seek out relevant research or explain to the patient that their personal experience may differ from what they find online or hear from professionals who rely solely on consensus. or position statements.

Questions for discussion

Do you mainly get your medical data from position statements? Have you noticed any differences between gender, race/ethnicity, or gender? If so, what have you done to fill the knowledge gaps in the position statements?

related posts

  1. Comparison of three new concussion guidelines
  2. Do sex and contraception affect recovery from a concussion?
  3. A Closer Look at Concussions 2016-202: Increasing Prevalence and Gender Differences
  4. Bottom line: what role do age and gender play after a concussion?

Written by: Jane McDevitt
Review by: Jeffrey Driban

Evidence-based assessment of concussion course - 5 EBP CEUs

Source link

Similar Posts

  • Activity affected urinary incontinence; Let’s talk about it!

      Prevalence and normalization of stress urinary incontinence in female strength athletes. Mahoney K, Heidel RE, and Olewinski LJ Good luck Cond2023 [epub ahead of print]. Full text freely available Take home message Seven in ten female strength training athletes report stress urinary incontinence (SUI) in some aspect of their lives. However, fewer than 2…

  • |

    Advanced Biologics takes biological innovations to the next level through a merger with Isto Biologics

    CARLSBAD, Calif., Oct. 18, 2023 /PRNewswire/ — Advanced Biologics (commercially known as Biologica Technologies), a California-based company known for their innovative biological solutions, today announced their successful merger with Isto Biologics, a global leader in regenerative and autologous therapies. The merger will seamlessly integrate Advanced Biologics’ proprietary products into Isto’s valued and growing portfolio of…

  • |

    Best knee scooter post-surgery

    Is hopping around on one leg or battling clumsy crutches the only way to get through recovery after a foot or ankle procedure? For many, traditional crutches are a source of frustration and fatigue. They demand considerable arm strength and often lead to instability. This can make you feel trapped and dependent on others. best knee scooter post-surgery There is a more comfortable and popular solution. Studies show that 90 percent of patients prefer using a knee scooter over crutches during their healing period. Occupational therapists highlight a key benefit: these aids keep your injured foot correctly elevated and non-weight bearing. This proper positioning is vital for a smooth recovery. We’ve done the research for you. Our analysis of the current market identifies devices that provide superior mobility and comfort compared to old-fashioned methods. Selecting the right walker helps you maintain your independence. It allows for safer movement around your home and community. A sturdy, well-designed walker is a much more stable alternative to risky hopping. Our expert-driven guide reviews the leading models available. The goal is to help you find reliable equipment that protects your leg while letting you continue with daily life. Key Takeaways The vast majority of patients prefer knee scooters to traditional crutches for recovery. These devices properly elevate the leg, which is essential for non-weight bearing healing. They promote greater independence and reduce reliance on others during your recovery. Choosing a high-quality model significantly improves safety and overall comfort. Our guide provides an expert analysis of the top mobility aids on the market today. A stable walker minimizes the risk of falls and accidental weight-bearing. Informed selection helps you navigate your environment with confidence and ease. Understanding Knee Scooters in Post-Surgery Recovery Patients seeking a stable alternative to crutches frequently turn to rolling walkers with a knee platform. This device, often called a knee scooter or knee walker, has two to five wheels and a padded rest for your leg. It is designed to keep your injured foot correctly elevated. This positioning is completely non-weight bearing, which is vital for healing. Unlike traditional crutches, a knee walker does not demand much arm strength. You simply rest your leg on the cushioned platform and propel yourself forward. This reduces physical exertion dramatically during daily movement. Occupational therapists note an overwhelming patient preference for this mobility aid. We have found that nearly 90 percent of users prefer it over other options. The design helps prevent reinjury caused by balance struggles. Feature Knee Scooter/Walker Traditional Crutches Weight-Bearing Non-weight bearing, leg elevated Partial weight on arms and shoulders Upper Body Strain Minimal; uses leg for support High; requires arm strength Hands-Free Operation Yes; handlebars for steering No; hands occupied Stability on Flat Surfaces Very stable with multiple wheels Less stable; two points of contact Risk of Reinjury Low; proper leg positioning Higher; balance challenges These devices are essential for maintaining independence. They allow you to perform household tasks while your injury heals. By keeping your hands free, a knee scooter lets you carry items and engage in daily life more effectively. Benefits of Using Knee Scooters Over Crutches The journey to regain mobility after surgery doesn’t have to be a struggle against discomfort and instability. While traditional crutches are less expensive, they frequently cause pain and balance issues for active individuals. A knee walker provides a stable base for movement. It allows you to navigate both indoors and outdoors without the constant fatigue linked to crutches. benefits of knee scooter over crutches Occupational therapists emphasize that a knee scooter is a superior choice if you lack upper body strength. Using this device greatly lowers your chance of a fall compared to balancing on underarm crutches. These aids offer a level of freedom that lets you spend time outside. This activity is proven to speed up the healing process. Choosing the right knee walker ensures you can maintain your daily routine. You avoid the physical limits imposed by standard crutches. A quality knee scooter supports your injured leg correctly, promoting safer recovery….

  • |

    Understanding osteoarthritis: symptoms, causes and treatment options

      Osteoarthritis is painful for many people and affects their daily activities and quality of life. The progression of this degenerative joint disease can be slow and gradual, leading to discomfort and movement limitations. Despite its prevalence, there is still much to learn about osteoarthritis and how to treat it effectively. Our blog article explores…

  • Sports managers need sports trainers for a better heat policy

      Exercise-induced heat illness: policy adoption and influence on contextual factors reported by athletic administrators Scarneo-Miller SE, Adams WM, Coleman KA, Lopez RM. Sports Health. Mar 5, 2023: 19417381231155107. doi: 10.1177/19417381231155107. E-publishing prior to printing. PMID: 36872595. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19417381231155107 Take home message Most high school athletic administrators reported having a written heat illness policy in place,…

  • | |

    Injury awareness: does stretching prevent injuries?

      It used to be believed that stretching before a workout was as important as eating breakfast before the start of a big day. If you want to minimize the risk of possible muscle tears, joint injuries or pain-free running, then stretching to prevent injuries is an essential part of your exercise regimen before you…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *