high school football 1228995 1920

“It’ll never happen to me” appears in the concussion reporting mess

 

Masculinity, optimism, and perceived stakeholder pressure influence concussion prevention intentions and behaviors in college students and athletes.

Weber Rawlins ML, Welch Bacon CE, Tomporowski P, Gay JL, Bierema L, Schmidt JD. J Am Coll Health. 2022 Sep 9:1-7. doi: 10.1080/07448481.2022.2115300. E-publishing prior to printing.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36084227/

Take home message

Student-athletes with a pessimistic view of concussion risk have higher intentions to report symptoms or a concussion.

Background

Doctors rely on student-athletes to report a possible concussion to ensure proper diagnosis and treatment. We can optimize education efforts to improve concussion reporting with a better understanding of the barriers to concussion reporting. Three emerging areas that may influence messaging are masculinity (qualities traditionally associated with men), optimism (thinking that bad things are less likely to happen to the person than others), and perceived pressure from stakeholders (e.g., coaches, teammates).

Study aim

Weber Rawlins and colleagues completed a survey study to determine how masculinity, optimism, and perceived pressure from others were related to reporting intentions and behavior.

Methods

Student-athletes from three universities in the southeastern US used online survey software to complete five tools that assessed key factors:

  1. masculinity (winning, emotional control, risk taking, violence, power over women, playboy, self-reliance, primacy of sports and heterosexual self-presentation)
  2. optimism bias
  3. perceived pressure (from coaches, teammates, parents/guardians, sports medicine professionals, athlete administrators, and sports fans)
  4. concussion and symptom reporting intentions (summarized as reporter or non-reporter)
  5. concussion and symptom reporting behavior (summarized as reporter or non-reporter)

Results

A total of 313 respondents completed all parts of the survey, and 369 respondents completed at least one part of the survey. A student-athlete was less likely to report symptoms or a concussion if he was not a pessimist (neutral or optimist). Furthermore, they were less likely to report symptoms if they reported higher levels of masculinity in two domains: “playboy” and “heterosexual self-preservation.” In terms of intent to report concussions, someone with higher scores for “primacy of the sport” and “pressure from athletic administration” was less likely to report it.

Viewpoints

Interestingly, the most consistent result was that someone who was neutral or less likely to experience bad events than someone else was less likely to report symptoms or a concussion. Based on this finding, the authors suggest that “educational efforts should emphasize the realistic risk that student-athletes have for sustaining a concussion in sport or developing long-term health consequences as a result of that concussion.” The authors also reported predictors of reporting behavior during the previous year. These analyzes led to different results than what we reported above. One explanation is that reporting intentions and actual behavior do not match. However, it is difficult to compare these results because only 10-20% of participants had symptoms or a concussion to report (or not report) in the previous year. Therefore, the different results could be a fluke, or this subset of people may be unique to the remaining 80-90% of participants without concussions or symptoms in the previous year. It will be interesting to see if future studies with a larger group of people with symptoms or concussions in the previous year yield similar results.

Clinical implications

Clinicians should encourage timely reporting of concussions and provide realistic estimates of a student-athlete’s risk for concussion and the consequences of a concussion.

Questions for discussion

What strategies have you used to educate stakeholders about the dangers of not reporting concussions? Have you found these efforts to be successful? Why or why not?

Written by: Kyle Harris
Review by: Jeffrey Driban

related posts

Better posture can improve concussion reporting habits
Concussion knowledge is getting better, but is reporting getting worse?
Knowledge of concussions does not translate into healthy reporting habits
Differences in symptom reporting between male and female athletes before and after concussion

Evidence-based assessment of concussion course - 5 EBP CEUs

Source link

Similar Posts

  • |

    Knee replacement rehab timeline

    What if the most critical part of your joint procedure happens after you leave the operating room? We understand that navigating the path to healing can feel overwhelming. Our guide is here to provide the clarity you need for a successful journey. knee replacement rehab timeline Data shows that movement often starts very quickly. Physical therapy typically begins within 24 hours after your procedure. This early step is vital for promoting faster healing and restoring mobility. For most people, the complete process of regaining strength spans several months. It’s a journey from the initial post-operative phase to full recovery, often taking between six and twelve months. We aim to help you manage expectations about the time required to return to the activities you love. While every patient’s experience is unique, understanding the general phases can significantly reduce anxiety. By following a structured plan, you can improve function and regain the independence you enjoyed before joint pain began. Your commitment to rehabilitation directly influences the long-term success of your new joint and overall health. Key Takeaways Physical activity often starts within a day of your procedure to aid healing. The full recovery process generally takes between six months and a year. Your personal journey is unique, but knowing common stages reduces worry. A structured plan is crucial for regaining function and independence. Your dedication to the process directly impacts your long-term results. This guide provides clarity to navigate each stage with confidence. Understanding Knee Replacement Surgery We believe informed patients are empowered patients, starting with the details of the operation itself. Knowing which procedure is right for you is a crucial first step in preparing for your healing journey. Differences Between Total and Partial Knee Replacement A total knee replacement involves resurfacing the entire joint with an artificial structure. Surgeons cut away worn cartilage and bone to create a new surface. In contrast, a partial knee replacement focuses only on the damaged compartment. This targeted approach often leads to a quicker recovery process with less discomfort. What to Expect During Surgery and Initial Recovery During your replacement surgery, the medical team precisely aligns the new components. This careful work is done to restore smooth movement and function. Your personal recovery timeline is influenced by factors like your age and general health. Understanding these differences helps you set realistic goals for after your knee surgery. The ultimate goal of this joint procedure is to provide lasting relief from chronic pain and improve your mobility. Immediate Post-Surgery Recovery The journey to regain your mobility starts the moment you wake from anesthesia. Your active participation is vital from these first hours. immediate post surgery recovery We emphasize that structured support begins almost immediately. This early phase sets the foundation for your entire healing process. Day 1: Initiating Rehabilitation and Mobility Physical therapy often starts within 24 hours of your procedure. Your physical therapist will help you take those first, crucial steps. They guide you in standing and walking with a walker or crutches. These initial sessions focus on basic, safe movements. You’ll practice sitting at the bedside and transferring your weight. This early activity promotes circulation and helps prevent complications. Transitioning from Hospital to Home Your medical team must see you meet specific safety criteria before discharge. You need to manage pain well and demonstrate independent movement. Key goals include standing from a chair and using the bathroom alone. Navigating a short flight of stairs is also a common requirement. Some individuals may leave the hospital on the same day as their operation. This is possible if all safety boxes are checked. Your care team will provide clear instructions for protecting your new joint. They will also give you simple exercises to continue at home. The First Week: Early Rehabilitation Steps Navigating the initial week after your operation requires a clear focus on gentle movement and symptom management. We guide you through this period where your routine prioritizes restoring a natural walking pattern and improving joint flexibility. early rehabilitation steps Guided Physical Therapy Exercises for Range of Motion During the first 48 hours, the primary goal is achieving full extension and increasing flexion. Your physical therapist will recommend specific movements to help. These early exercises are designed to prevent stiffness and promote circulation. Your daily routine is crucial for maintaining flexibility in this joint. Managing Pain, Swelling, and Initial Activity Controlling discomfort is a priority. Your doctor may advise using ice packs, elevating your leg, and taking medication as directed. You must monitor your incision site closely. The American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons suggests waiting 5 to 7 days before showering if non-waterproof dressings are used. We encourage gentle activity, like using a stationary bike. This helps the area regain strength without overexertion. If you experience severe pain or excessive swelling, stop and consult your physical therapist or surgeon immediately. Following a structured rehabilitation timeline is key for a successful recovery….

  • Best ice machine for knee surgery (Game Ready, Polar Care)

    What if you could recover from knee surgery with less pain and fewer medications? This question is at the heart of modern post-operative care. Managing discomfort and swelling is a major challenge after an orthopedic procedure. cold therapy system Cold therapy offers a powerful, drug-free solution. It is a non-invasive method to control inflammation and pain directly at the source. Specialized units deliver consistent cooling to the affected area. This can significantly reduce the need for strong painkillers during the critical healing phase. We have thoroughly examined the market of recovery tools. Our guide focuses on leading systems, including various Breg Polar Care models and the Game Ready unit. Our goal is to help you navigate your options. You can find a system that fits your needs and supports a smoother, more comfortable recovery at home. Key Takeaways Cold therapy is a proven, drug-free method to manage pain and swelling after surgery. Using a dedicated cooling unit can help reduce reliance on narcotic pain medication. Popular systems like the Breg Polar Care line come in several models, such as the Cube, Kodiak, Glacier, and Wave. Game Ready is a leading unit that combines cold therapy with adjustable compression. Always consult your healthcare provider to ensure this therapy is right for your specific procedure. Selecting the right device involves considering your budget and recovery goals. Effective, consistent cooling can greatly improve comfort and outcomes during the healing process. Introduction to Knee Surgery Recovery and Cold Therapy Successfully navigating the first weeks post-surgery hinges on a structured recovery strategy. This plan must prioritize managing two key issues: discomfort and inflammation. This is where cold therapy, also called cryotherapy, becomes essential. It involves applying controlled cooling to the surgical area to reduce inflammation. After a procedure, fluid often accumulates in the joint. This swelling, known as edema, increases pressure and causes significant pain. The therapy works by constricting blood vessels. This action helps limit the amount of fluid and blood pooling at the injury site. Many surgeons now recommend a dedicated cooling device. These units provide consistent, targeted cold therapy that is far more effective than basic ice packs. Reducing swelling early is crucial. It directly supports efforts to regain a full range of motion in the knee during rehabilitation. Healthcare providers often prescribe this therapy as a safe alternative to stronger pain medications. Patients should always combine its use with specific exercise advice from a physiotherapist. This promotes healthy blood flow and ensures optimal healing. How Cold Therapy Works in Reducing Swelling and Pain Cold therapy targets the root causes of post-operative discomfort through a simple yet powerful process. It directly addresses the inflammation and pain that hinder healing. Mechanism of Action in Cold Therapy The primary mechanism involves using cold water to constrict blood vessels. This reduces blood flow and inflammation in the affected area. A dedicated unit provides a continuous, even distribution of this chilled liquid. It maintains a steady cold temperature for many hours. cold therapy mechanism Advantages Over Traditional Ice Packs Basic ice packs warm up quickly due to body heat. Their effectiveness diminishes within minutes. In contrast, a motorized therapy system eliminates frequent trips to the freezer. Its large, insulated reservoir ensures prolonged cooling. Specialized pads are designed for specific body parts. They deliver targeted cold therapy exactly where needed. This approach prevents the condensation issues of melting ice packs. It keeps the surgical site clean and dry, enhancing comfort and hygiene. Overview of Cold Therapy Devices for Post-Surgical Recovery The market offers two primary types of cold therapy units, each with distinct mechanisms and benefits. Selecting the right one depends on your mobility, budget, and recovery goals. We categorize these devices into gravity-fed and motorized systems. This helps you understand which technology best suits your specific needs. Types of Devices: Motorized and Gravity-Fed Systems Gravity-fed devices, like the Aircast Cryo/Cuff, use elevation to circulate water without a motor. They are cost-effective and portable. The simple physics of elevation moves chilled liquid through the pad. Motorized systems provide constant recirculation of cold water between a cooler and the pad. This is ideal for patients with limited mobility after a procedure. Brands like Breg Polar Care circulate water directly for efficient cooling. The DonJoy IceMan series uses dual pump technology for a comfortable temperature. Some advanced therapy units, such as the Ossur Cold Rush, feature an adjustable flow dial. This allows patients to customize their experience. Understanding these mechanical differences is key before making a purchase. Both types deliver effective cold therapy, but their operation varies. Key Features to Consider When Purchasing an Ice Machine Several practical factors determine how well a cold therapy machine will serve you at home. The right features enhance both effectiveness and convenience during your healing period. Consistency, Coverage, and Temperature Control Look for a unit that maintains a steady cold temperature. Consistent cooling is vital for safe, prolonged sessions. Good coverage means the pad fits your joint properly. This ensures the therapy reaches all affected areas. Adjustable controls let you fine-tune the intensity. This prevents skin irritation while maximizing comfort. cold therapy…

  • |

    Flying after knee replacement

    What if the freedom to travel by air after major joint surgery isn’t as far off as you think? We understand this is a common concern. Many people who have undergone this significant orthopedic procedure worry about their next trip. flying after knee replacement Research shows that managing mobility after an operation is crucial. For instance, data indicates 3-4% of total hip arthroplasty patients develop symptomatic blood clots within three months. Our guide provides essential information for navigating air travel following a successful procedure. We aim to help you feel confident and prepared for your journey. You may wonder when it is safe to resume your plans. We explore how to manage your healing while looking ahead. By following expert-backed advice, you can minimize potential issues. Our focus is on helping you enjoy your restored mobility with peace of mind. Key Takeaways Air travel is a major concern for individuals recovering from joint surgery. Proper planning is essential for a safe and comfortable journey post-operation. Understanding the risks, like blood clots (VTE), is a critical part of preparation. Timing your trip correctly is a key milestone in the overall recovery process. Expert guidance can help reduce complications and build confidence. The goal is to regain freedom of movement and enjoy travel without worry. Understanding the Risks and Benefits of Flying after Knee Replacement The decision to fly after a major joint procedure requires a careful look at safety data and personal mobility gains. We break down the key factors to consider. Assessing Venous Thromboembolism (VTE) Risk A primary concern is venous thromboembolism, which includes deep vein thrombosis (DVT). Research shows the risk of symptomatic VTE after long flights is 1.9 to 5.2 per million person-days. For individuals who have had joint surgery, this risk is heightened. Studies indicate 3-4% of patients develop symptomatic clots within three months of a procedure like total hip arthroplasty. Balancing Recovery and Mobility Benefits The significant improvement in movement is a major positive outcome. However, balancing this benefit with the inherent dangers of blood clots requires medical guidance. Understanding these risks empowers people to make informed choices about travel timing. For comprehensive safety tips, see our detailed guide on flying after knee replacement. Pre-Flight Preparation for Knee Replacement Patients A successful journey begins long before you reach the airport, especially following a significant orthopedic operation. Proper groundwork is essential for safety and comfort. This phase involves close collaboration with your medical team. It also requires a tailored strategy for your specific needs. Consulting with Your Surgeon and Healthcare Team Your first step is to get clear guidance from your orthopedic surgeon. They understand your unique situation best. Dr. Nathan Cafferky of The Steadman Clinic recommends a two-week recovery period near the surgical site before returning home. This allows for immediate post-operative care and monitoring. consulting surgeon for knee surgery travel plan We advise creating a personalized plan with your doctor. This consultation is vital for setting a safe timeline. Creating a Personalized Recovery and Travel Plan Dr. Cafferky also suggests avoiding nonessential trips for six weeks post-surgery. This waiting time helps ensure full healing. Your plan should coordinate support from your entire care team. Focus on rehabilitation during the initial weeks. This approach minimizes risks and builds a solid foundation for future mobility. A thoughtful strategy makes the transition back to daily life much smoother. Planning Your Travel Itinerary and Navigating Airline Requirements Understanding specific carrier policies can make or break your travel plans post-surgery. We guide you through this essential step. Your itinerary must account for unique airline rules. These rules directly impact individuals recovering from an operation. Reviewing Airline Policies and Certification Requirements Research reveals varied carrier stances. A UK study found five airlines restrict flying following arthroplasty. Seven carriers mandate a medical certificate from your doctor. One even requires a 14-day waiting period post-procedure. Always verify your airline’s specific policy before booking. This is a critical precaution for all patients. Policy Type Medical Certificate Required Typical Waiting Period Restricted (No travel allowed) N/A…

  • Attending live sports improves well-being: study

      New scientific research has found that attending live sporting events improves levels of wellbeing and reduces feelings of loneliness. Published in the magazine Frontiers in public healthThe study is the first large-scale study to examine the benefits of attending any type of live sporting event. The research, conducted by academics from Anglia Ruskin University’s…

  • |

    Influence of cuff stiffness on hemodynamics and perceived cuff pressure in the upper limbs in men and women: implications for practical training to limit blood flow restriction BMC Sports sciences, medicine and rehabilitation

      All participants (demographic and anthropometric data are shown in Table 1) successfully completed the experimental sessions without side effects, except for some cases of mild tingling in the fingers at the end of the measurements. Regarding RTD, three men had to be excluded from the data analyzes because the occlusion of arterial blood flow…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *